Written By: Ben Cosgrove

Marilyn Monroe and baseball legend Joe DiMaggio wed in 1954 (second marriages for both), and were divorced nine months later. That the union was doomed from the beginning was, perhaps, easy to foresee. But even if the marriage was not a happy one for either of the two famous partners, there seems to be little doubt that there really was genuine affection there at the start and at the end. In fact, after Monroe’s divorce from her third husband, the playwright Arthur Miller, was finalized in 1961, DiMaggio came back into her life and, by all accounts, desperately tried to bring some stability and calm to an existence that was veering dangerously out of control.

He tried to get her away from people who, to his mind, were nothing but trouble (including, it seems, the Kennedys), and even proposed to her, asking her to marry him again. It’s awful, now, to think that if Marilyn had been given a little more time, DiMaggio could have been just the person to pull her back from the brink of depression, drugs, disastrous affairs with married men. In other words, he might have saved her life.

But a year and a half after her marriage to Miller ended, Marilyn all of 36 years old was dead. DiMaggio, it seems, could not protect her from whatever demons drove her. He was only in his 40s when Marilyn died on August 5, 1962, but he never married again.

Here, LIFE.com presents pictures from October 6, 1954, when Marilyn stepped out of the house on North Palm Drive in Beverly Hills to announce she was seeking a divorce from DiMaggio on the grounds of “mental cruelty.” DiMaggio had initially been drawn (like a few hundred million other men) to Marilyn’s “sex goddess” persona but he was never comfortable with her flaunting it, and was something of a self-admitted control freak. Neither DiMaggio nor Monroe could possibly have been content or satisfied in a marriage in which two such divergent personalities held sway.

The photographs here are not pleasant. They’re not easy to look at. There’s real pain in Marilyn’s face, posture and demeanor.

Still, these pictures tell a small but integral part of the Marilyn Monroe story, and capture the star at a pivotal point in her fraught life. She would marry again. She would make more movies in the coming years, including several classics. But deeper and more enduring pain was also in her future.

Of the October 1954 divorce filing, meanwhile, LIFE told its readers:

Even for Hollywood, where unhappy endings for the real love stories come with almost unseemly haste, this ending seemed abrupt. It was only last January that the press was mobbing the San Francisco city hall, waiting for Joe DiMaggio and Marilyn Monroe to emerge as newlywed man and wife. Now the press was gathered again in front of the DiMaggio home in Beverly Hills, waiting for Joe and Marilyn to come out as newly-separated man and wife.

Nobody had been surprised when they got married—they had been going with each other for two years. Nobody doubted their love they had smiled happily through their married life. And almost nobody professed surprised when they broke up. The conflict in their two careers seemed inevitable.

Marilyn Monroe at the time she filed for divorce from Joe DiMaggio, October 1954.

Marilyn Monroe divorce announcement 1954

George Silk The LIFE Picture Collection/Getty Images

Marilyn Monroe at the time she filed for divorce from Joe DiMaggio, October 1954.

Marilyn Monroe at the time she filed for divorce from Joe DiMaggio, Beverly Hills, October 1954.

George Silk The LIFE Picture Collection/Getty Images

Marilyn Monroe at the time she filed for divorce from Joe DiMaggio, October 1954.

Marilyn Monroe and her lawyer, Jerry Giesler, at the time she filed for divorce from Joe DiMaggio, Beverly Hills, October 1954.

George Silk The LIFE Picture Collection/Getty Images

Marilyn Monroe at the time she filed for divorce from Joe DiMaggio, October 1954.

Marilyn Monroe at the time she filed for divorce from Joe DiMaggio, Beverly Hills, October 1954.

George Silk The LIFE Picture Collection/Getty Images

Marilyn Monroe at the time she filed for divorce from Joe DiMaggio, October 1954.

Marilyn Monroe at the time she filed for divorce from Joe DiMaggio, Beverly Hills, October 1954.

George Silk The LIFE Picture Collection/Getty Images

Marilyn Monroe at the time she filed for divorce from Joe DiMaggio, October 1954.

Marilyn Monroe at the time she filed for divorce from Joe DiMaggio, Beverly Hills, October 1954.

George Silk The LIFE Picture Collection/Getty Images

Marilyn Monroe at the time she filed for divorce from Joe DiMaggio, October 1954.

The contact sheet of George Silk’s photos from the press conference announcing Marilyn Monroe’s divorce from Joe DiMaggio.

George Silk The LIFE Picture Collection/Getty Images

More Like This

people

Michelle Obama: Her Inspiring Story

Night with Frank Sinatra people

A Night Out With Sinatra

Christian Dior people

Christian Dior’s Conquering Eye

people

Celebrities’ Best Friends

George H.W. Bush and family at home in 1971. Left-Right: Nephew Billy, daughter Dorothy, George H.W., son Neil, wife Barbara, nephew Jon. people

The Family Life of a Young George H.W. Bush

John Wayne photo essay by John Dominis for LIFE magazine, 1969. people

Behind the Scenes With John Wayne, 1969